Metro Weekly

Sorry, anti-LGBT politicians, your “thoughts and prayers” aren’t good enough

Politicians who normally pass anti-LGBT legislation are offering condolences -- and Twitter isn't happy

Photo: Marco Rubio. Credit: Gage Skidmore/flickr.

Photo: Marco Rubio. Credit: Gage Skidmore/flickr.

America has two troubling constants. First is that with such an overwhelming number of guns in our society (about 4 million of them rifles) and lax regulation, mass shootings are going to happen. Second is that when those mass shootings do occur, politicians will offer their “thoughts and prayers,” then resume taking NRA funds to block any attempts at curbing future shootings.

After yesterday’s tragic events in Orlando, however, that second constant has taken on a rather twisted nature. As condolences flocked in for the families and victims of the Pulse Orlando nightclub massacre, which left 50 dead and another 53 injured, among them were a number of staunchly anti-LGBT politicians.

Given Pulse was an LGBT nightclub and the dead are presumably mostly LGBT or queer-identifying, we have an odd dichotomy where many politicians who work tirelessly to strip rights from LGBT people are expressing sadness at a barbaric event in that community. Of course, expressing condolences is only human; the problem is that these same politicians helped engender the environment that led to so many deaths.

Whether through anti-trans bathroom bills, attempts to block marriage equality, discriminatory “religious freedom” laws, or just being openly homophobic or transphobic, the conservative Right in America has helped foster a section of our country that is entirely hostile to LGBT people and everything we stand for. While they predominantly focus on the religion of yesterday’s shooter, Omar Mateen’s father offered another explanation for why his son brought a rifle and a handgun into an LGBT nightclub: he just didn’t like gay people.

“He saw two men kissing each other in front of his wife and kid and he got very angry,” Mir Seddique told NBC News.

Mateen, a U.S.-born American citizen, grew up in a country that, at least in part, fosters anti-queer sentiment. These same politicians that rushed to condemn his actions help to further that sentiment. It was a connection that many on Twitter seized upon.

Let’s take a look at some of the politicians who offered condolences and tweets yesterday.

Mike Huckabee

Mike Huckabee, former Governor of Arkansas and failed presidential candidate, believes gay relationships have the “ick factor.” He opposes marriage equality, once called homosexuality a lifestyle choice like drinking alcohol, slammed the nomination of Eric Fanning, an openly gay man, as Army Secretary, and was called “disgusting” for comments he made about trans students.

Ted Cruz

In a lengthy statement posted to his Facebook page, predominantly aimed at blaming Islam for the shootings, Sen. Ted Cruz made a rather curious statement.

“For all the Democrats who are loud champions of the gay and lesbian community whenever there is a culture battle waging, now is the opportunity to speak out against an ideology that calls for the murder of gays and lesbians,” he wrote.

He both belittles the efforts of Democratic politicians to halt or reverse the damage wreaked by the Republican party on the LGBT community, as well as inferring that he has the moral high ground on LGBT issues by supporting carpet bombing ISIS. From someone as vehemently anti-LGBT as Ted Cruz, that’s laughable. Indeed, he once tried to get journalists to stop commenting on how homophobic he is by saying that, unlike ISIS, he doesn’t throw people off buildings.

No, instead he considers marriage equality one of the “darkest hours of our nation,” believes that President Obama is more concerned with “promoting homosexuality in the military” than defeating extremists, and thinks that homosexuality is a choice. And let’s not get started on the ridiculously transphobic things he’s said.

Marco Rubio

Sen. Marco Rubio was one of the first to connect the dots between the shooter and the LGBT community, telling CNN “he targeted the gay community,” and urged people to donate blood for victims. However, Rubio also focused on Mateen’s religious background, blaming the shooting on Islamic extremism. He then said: “We have seen the way radical Islamists have treated gays and lesbians in other countries.”

It was an unfortunate choice of words, as Senator Rubio hasn’t exactly been the gold standard of treatment in Florida. He openly flaunted his opposition to marriage equality during his failed bid for president, denounced marriage equality when it was legalized in Florida, opposes employment nondiscrimination protections for LGBT people, helped raise money for a backer of “ex-gay” conversion therapy, and opposes gay adoption as children shouldn’t “be part of a social experiment.”

And there’s more

A host of right-wing politicians offered messages or statements in the wake of the attacks, each of them ignoring their anti-LGBT pasts to mourn the lives of people they would otherwise have thrown under the bus for an extra vote.

  • Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker tweeted “I extend our prayers for those killed.” Last year, he told CNN “I don’t know” when asked if being gay was a choice, he opposes marriage equality, and as a county executive “opposed even basic rights for LGBT couples.”
  • Speaker of the House Paul Ryan said it was “horrifying to see so many innocent lives cut short by such cowardice.” He wanted to keep Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell, opposes gay adoption, supports a constitutional ban on same-sex marriage, and recently helped his Republican colleagues pass legislation with an anti-LGBT amendment.
  • Former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin tweeted her (all-caps) “profound sorrow for victims.” Palin helped give rise to the large bloc of Tea Party Republicans in Congress, who work their hardest to oppose LGBT rights. She opposes same-sex marriage and recently posted an anti-trans image to her Facebook after an ESPN anchor was fired for his transphobic comments.
  • Indiana Gov. Mike Pence said he was “saddened by the horrific news” on Twitter, but happily signed into law Indiana’s anti-LGBT “religious freedom” bill last year, despite widespread criticism.
  • North Carolina Gov. Pat McCrory issued a statement calling it “a tragedy” and “something that should never take place in our country,” but he signed the state’s anti-LGBT HB 2 into law this year, which forces trans people to use a restroom that corresponds with their birth gender.

Just last month, almost 300 Congresspeople passed the National Defense Authorization Act, which allowed employment discrimination against LGBT people by federal contractors.

We’re willing to bet that quite a few of the names on that list issued condolences after yesterday’s shootings, but none batted an eyelid when it came time to strip LGBT people of their rights.

In a time of tragedy, it’s only natural to express grief, sorrow, anger or offer support to the families and friends of the victims. But when it’s a tragedy that so explicitly targeted the LGBT community, thanks in part to a hostile environment perpetuated by the very politicians who are now rushing to send their “prayers” to Orlando, a line must be drawn.

Rather than send empty tweets and issue nondescript statements, those who’ve worked so hard to keep LGBT people as second-class citizens would do well to examine exactly why someone decided to take a rifle into an LGBT nightclub.

Here’s a hint: hating LGBT people isn’t exclusive to Islamic extremism. You’re just using legislation instead of guns.

Rhuaridh Marr is Metro Weekly's managing editor. He can be reached at rmarr@metroweekly.com.

Leave a Comment: