The Obama administration called on the Supreme Court to strike down Proposition 8 in a brief filed today, declaring the California ban on same-sex marriage unconstitutional.
Solicitor General Donald Verrilli wrote on behalf of the Obama administration in the brief that California’s ban on same-sex marriage violates the 14th Amendment’s guarantee of equal protection.
“Proposition 8’s denial of marriage to same-sex couples, particularly where California at the same time grants same-sex partners all the substantive rights of marriage, violates equal protection,” the brief reads, adding that “heightened scrutiny” should be applied in the case because of the history of discrimination faced by gays and lesbians.
Although the brief was not a sweeping call for the high court to strike down same-sex marriage bans across the nation, which is not an issue before the court, the arguments made by the administration in the brief against California’s ban could be applied in other states.
“I think the solicitor general has left open and charted a course that if followed in other states would require those laws to be struck down too,” American Foundation for Equal Rights (AFER) attorney Ted Boutrous said of the arguments made in the brief during a conference call with reporters.
“This is really the last group in America who is being discriminated against because of their status,” Boutrous added. “This is a really important day in our nation’s history where the United States government has said in a brief in the Supreme Court basically, this discrimination cannot be tolerated.”
Taking issue with many of the arguments made by proponents of Proposition 8, which was approved by California voters in 2008 and banned same-sex marriage after that right was already granted to gay couples, the brief states that “reference to tradition, no matter how long established, cannot by itself justify a discriminatory law under equal protection principles.”
California’s extension of all of the substantive rights and responsibilities of marriage to gay and lesbian domestic partners particularly undermines the justifications for Proposition 8. It indicates that Proposition 8’s withholding of the designation of marriage is not based on an interest in promoting responsible procreation and child-rearing—petitioners’ central claimed justification for the initiative—but instead on impermissible prejudice.
“Prejudice may not, however, be the basis for differential treatment under the law,” the brief concludes.
The filing today was one of dozens of briefs filed today by various groups and businesses calling on the high court to strike down Proposition 8 and comes on the final day the court is accepting amicus curiae briefs. But today’s brief was also a landmark move on the part of the Obama administration and another step in the president’s long evolution on same-sex marriage. The filing comes after weeks of lobbying by plaintiffs in the case, who have urged the president to weigh in and insisted a brief from the administration would aid their cause and fuel the political climate that can affect the opinions of justices seeking to be on the right side of history.
While Obama made history in May 2012 as the first sitting president to endorse same-sex marriage and has slammed the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act as unconstitutional, he had not commented on the Proposition 8 case. Since the Supreme Court announced in December they would hear arguments on the case, the White House has refused to comment on whether the administration would weigh in. As recently as this afternoon White House press secretary Jay Carney would not say if the administration would weigh in.
“In our filing today in Hollingsworth v. Perry, the government seeks to vindicate the defining constitutional ideal of equal treatment under the law,” Attorney General Eric Holder said in a statement after the filing. “Throughout history, we have seen the unjust consequences of decisions and policies rooted in discrimination. The issues before the Supreme Court in this case and the Defense of Marriage Act case are not just important to the tens of thousands Americans who are being denied equal benefits and rights under our laws, but to our Nation as a whole.”
The brief makes many of the arguments attorneys for AFER, led by Ted Olson and David Boies, have made over the years as the case has been litigated in lower courts. Adam Umhoefer, executive director of AFER, described the brief as “unprecedented.”
“The brief filed by the Solicitor General is a powerful statement that Proposition 8 cannot be squared with the principles of equality upon which this nation was founded,” Umhoefer said in a statement. “It is an unprecedented call to action by our Government that it is time to recognize gay and lesbian Americans as full and equal citizens under the law.”
According to Human Rights Campaign President Chad Griffin, who cofounded AFER and recruited Olson and Boies to the lead the legal fight against Proposition 8 in 2009, today’s filing was reflective of the central argument of their case: that the Constitution guarantees all Americans equal protection.
“It is enormously gratifying to know that today, that the President and U.S. Government are standing with us against marriage discrimination,” Griffin said.
Oral arguments are scheduled to begin before the Supreme Court on March 26 with a ruling expected in June.
[Photo: Barack Obama, Eric Holder and Joe Biden (Official White House photo by Pete Souza).]
Bishop O'Dowd High School, a 75-year-old Catholic college-preparatory school in East Oakland, California, has adopted a new rainbow logo after the Diocese of Oakland forced it to remove LGBTQ Pride flags from classrooms before the start of the school year.
The Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland asked O'Dowd administrators last winter to remove the school's rainbow and transgender Pride flags, an employee told The Oaklandside. The flags were taken down on June 1, 2026 without any formal communication to students or families, although staff marked their removal with a ceremony, according to the employee. At least one of the flags had hung in a classroom for more than 30 years.
Two gay bars in San Francisco's Castro district say they have paused their use of a controversial ID-scanning system that photographs patrons following backlash from the local LGBTQ community.
In June, local news outlet Gazetteer reported that at least three LGBTQ bars -- The Mix, Badlands, and Toad Hall -- were using PatronScan Guard+, an ID-scanning system that photographs patrons and stores their images in a database.
The database contains a patron's zip code, birth date, gender, ID expiration date, and photograph. Patronscan says the photograph serves only as a time-stamped record of the patron's appearance and is not used for facial recognition or biometric identification.
Long Beach police arrested a man accused of making violent threats in the comments of a social media post promoting the Big Gay Flotilla, an annual informal gay beach party and meet-up where attendees bring pool floats and water gear to swim, sunbathe, and socialize.
The man was among several people who commented on an event flyer posted to the Instagram account of Long Beach Classic, a local news website. The AI-generated flyer promoted the "Big Gay Float Party in Long Beach," scheduled for August 8 at Horny Corner in Belmont Shore, and depicted gay men in swimming trunks, including one wearing a rainbow-colored thong and walking into the water.
These are challenging times for news organizations. And yet it’s crucial we stay active and provide vital resources and information to both our local readers and the world. So won’t you please take a moment and consider supporting Metro Weekly with a membership? For as little as $5 a month, you can help ensure Metro Weekly magazine and MetroWeekly.com remain free, viable resources as we provide the best, most diverse, culturally-resonant LGBTQ coverage in both the D.C. region and around the world. Memberships come with exclusive perks and discounts, your own personal digital delivery of each week’s magazine (and an archive), access to our Member's Lounge when it launches this fall, and exclusive members-only items like Metro Weekly Membership Mugs and Tote Bags! Check out all our membership levels here and please join us today!
