Metro Weekly

Single Carrot Theatre’s “Peter Pan” incorporates “a bunch of different queer narratives”

Baltimore theater presents a new adaptation of Peter Pan developed with the local LGBTQ community

Peter Pan — Photo: Britt Olsen-Ecker

“So many [LGBTQ] people we met told us that from childhood Peter Pan is the one fairytale they have connected with,” says Single Carrot Theatre’s Ben Kleymeyer. “To be able to give it back to the community in a way that more specifically reflects their lives and their stories is really powerful.”

Kleymeyer is the community liaison for the Baltimore theater troupe, as well as a member of its acting ensemble. He’s starring as Peter Pan in its latest production.

“In many ways it’s the same Peter Pan story that people know,” says director Tristan Powell. “The difference is that we’ve incorporated a bunch of different queer narratives for the characters so that, for example, Tink is a character who pines after Peter and desperately wants to be with Peter — is in love with Peter, wants to sleep with Peter, but can’t because her body is too small. Hook and Smee [also] have a relationship.”

Los Angeles-based playwright Joshua Conkel developed his queer adaptation — which he titled Wendy, Peter. Peter, Wendy — through the community engagement initiative of Single Carrot. Conkel and the company held meetings and workshops with LGBTQ service organizations, businesses, and community members. “Their stories became the source material for what’s onstage,” says Kleymeyer.

Some of those same community members auditioned and now perform in the work. “This is a really unique project for a number of reasons,” says Powell, a New York-based theater artist. “Definitely that we’re queering the canon, and also that several of the performers have no experience whatsoever… That was a little new on my end as a director.”

“There’s a lot more flexibility about who you can be in Neverland — and how you can change and how people will relate to you once you’ve changed,” Powell continues. “There are tensions between the different groups of Neverland, just as there are tensions within the queer community between different populations.”

Finally, there’s the relationship at the heart of the tale, that between Peter and Wendy, two kids “questioning and navigating who they are.”

Says Powell, “Where they go and what happens to them in their journey, flying to Neverland and coming home, changes them. The tail end of our story is radically different from the original and offers a completely new interpretation of the characters.”

Wendy, Peter. Peter, Wendy runs to May 20 at Single Carrot Theatre, 2600 N Howard St., in Baltimore. Tickets are $25 to $29. Call 443-844-9253 or visit

Please Support Metro Weekly

As a free LGBTQ publication, Metro Weekly relies on advertising in order to bring you unique, high quality journalism, both online and in our weekly edition. The ongoing coronavirus pandemic has forced many of our incredible advertisers to temporarily close their doors to protect staff and customers, and so we’re asking you, our readers, to help support Metro Weekly during this trying period. We appreciate anything you can do, and please keep reading us on the website and our new Digital Edition, released every Thursday and available for online reading or download.

Doug Rule covers the arts, theater, music, food, nightlife and culture as contributing editor for Metro Weekly.

Leave a Comment: