Metro Weekly

Gay Father Charged After Punching Right-Wing Influencer

The incident followed a street interview in which a right-wing commentator asked the couple inflammatory questions about same-sex parenting.

Ryley Niemi – @RyleyNiemi_ on X

A gay father has been arrested and charged with felony vandalism after punching a right-wing social media personality who approached him and his husband while they were walking with their baby.

Video posted to Instagram by conservative commentator Ryley Niemi shows him approaching Anthony Vulin, a member of West Hollywood’s Business License Commission, and his husband, David, on Santa Monica Boulevard.

In the video, Niemi appears to conduct a man-on-the-street-style interview about same-sex parenting, but his questions echo common conservative talking points portraying gay men as child molesters or equating surrogacy with human trafficking.

“Have you ever heard about the statistics coming out that gay men are much more likely to commit child molestation?” Niemi asks. The couple appears shocked and says they have not, calling the claim “crazy.”

“Don’t you think it’s weird that you guys have a child but neither of you are a woman?” Niemi continues.

“No,” responds Anthony Vulin.

Niemi asks whether the couple used a surrogate. When they don’t respond, he says, “You paid a woman $50,000 to be pregnant?”

As the couple starts to walk away, David Vulin shouts at Niemi, “Who the fuck are you? I’m gonna fucking kick your ass,” and shoves him.

The edited footage then cuts to a fight in which David Vulin strikes Niemi in the head. A police officer appears in the background as the confrontation unfolds. The video also shows a passerby who had earlier helped break up the altercation telling Niemi and his crew they “deserve to be killed” before walking away.

In the video caption, Niemi claimed the man who struck him could face felony charges and that a $2,500 camera was broken during the encounter. He also linked to a fundraising page seeking donations for new equipment and security.

In a follow-up video, Niemi said that he tried to de-escalate the situation and claimed the couple “seemed to not care for their own baby’s safety.”

“If we were men who were morally delinquent, we may have fought back and hurt that baby,” he said. “But we do not do that.”

The couple tells a different story.

Anthony Vulin told the WeHo Times that he and his husband were walking when they were approached by four men — three with cameras — who claimed to be from CNN and asked them to participate in an interview about gay parenting.

Vulin said the questions quickly turned confrontational, and the situation escalated.

“They started right off the bat asking if we were aware of studies saying gay men who are parents are more likely to be child molesters,” he said. “People started pushing each other, and they were pushing me while I was holding the baby.”

Anthony Vulin also claimed that he and his husband were victims of a hate crime and that Niemi used anti-gay slurs. It was then that David Vulin struck Niemi, and the couple left the scene and went to the West Hollywood Sheriff’s Station to report the incident.

Anthony Vulin said deputies arrested his husband after he acknowledged striking someone during the confrontation. David Vulin was held for about 12 hours before being released. He said his husband was booked on a charge related to allegedly damaging camera equipment during the altercation.

“They said he broke a camera, which he didn’t,” he said. “Now we have to fight that.”

David Vulin was charged with a felony for “vandalism with loss valued equal or greater than $400.”

Many commenters on the Instagram video appeared to side with the Vulins.

“Go ask a straight couple questions implying they molest their newborn and I guarantee you the man will immediately behave aggressively to defend his family,” said one commentor. “That’s what happened in this video.”

“This isn’t a real conversation, it’s staged provocation,” wrote another. “Approaching a family with a baby and pressing them with loaded accusing questions isn’t a debate, it’s harassment for content.”

Anthony Vulin has launched a GoFundMe campaign seeking $100,000 to help cover his husband’s legal costs. The campaign has raised more than $59,000.

Support Metro Weekly’s Journalism

These are challenging times for news organizations. And yet it’s crucial we stay active and provide vital resources and information to both our local readers and the world. So won’t you please take a moment and consider supporting Metro Weekly with a membership? For as little as $5 a month, you can help ensure Metro Weekly magazine and MetroWeekly.com remain free, viable resources as we provide the best, most diverse, culturally-resonant LGBTQ coverage in both the D.C. region and around the world. Memberships come with exclusive perks and discounts, your own personal digital delivery of each week’s magazine (and an archive), access to our Member's Lounge when it launches this fall, and exclusive members-only items like Metro Weekly Membership Mugs and Tote Bags! Check out all our membership levels here and please join us today!