The Department of Justice filed a brief on Nov. 10 arguing that a lawsuit filed by Chelsea Manning against the department should be dismissed. Manning is suing the department for its refusal to allow her to follow female grooming standards consistent with her gender identity.
Manning, a former U.S. Army private, came out as transgender in 2013, one day after being sentenced to 35 years in prison for releasing more than 700,000 government files containing sensitive information to the online government watchdog site Wikileaks. It was one of the largest leaks of classified documents in American history.
Since that time, Manning and her lawyers have battled with government officials over Manning’s recommended treatment for gender dysphoria.
As a result of a lawsuit filed in September 2014 against then-Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel — and other officials from the Department of Defense and the U.S. Army — the government agreed to allow Manning to receive hormone therapy, speech therapy and cosmetics, but has refused to allow her to grow out her hair. Manning has promised to fight the decision, arguing that it is part of her necessary treatment for gender dysphoria.
The DOJ has argued that Manning must comply with the same grooming standards as other inmates at the United States Disciplinary Barracks (USDB) in Leavenworth, Kansas. The USDB is a maximum-security facility for men, meaning all prisoners must have hair no longer than two inches in length.
“As described in Manning’s Amended Complaint, Manning is currently receiving a significant amount of medical treatment for her gender dysphoria. Specifically, Manning is receiving weekly psychotherapy, including psychotherapy specific to gender dysphoria, the provision of female undergarments, permission to wear prescribed cosmetics in her daily life at the USDB, speech therapy, and cross-sex hormone therapy,” the DOJ writes in its request to have Manning’s lawsuit dismissed.
“Notwithstanding all of these treatments, Manning claims that Defendants have violated the Eighth Amendment by not permitting her to wear a feminine hairstyle…consistent with what is permitted for inmates at the military’s female prison,” the brief continues. “Separately, Manning also claims that the USDB’s enforcement of its hair restriction violates the Fifth Amendment’s guarantee of equal protection, because inmates in the military’s female prison are permitted to have longer hair.
“The issue before this court is quite narrow — whether the USDB, a military prison for men, is required to stop enforcing its military grooming standards and allow Manning, an incarcerated transgender female, to grow her hair longer than what is permitted for the rest of her fellow prisoners,” the DOJ argues. “This narrow issue is fundamentally intertwined, however, with preserving core prison-security and military values at the UDSB, such as uniform treatment and good order and discipline. Manning asks this Court to second-guess the considered determinations of military and corrections professionals as how best to protect those interests.”
The brief also argues that preventing Manning from growing out her hair is for her own good, as a way to protect her from potential assaults that she might be subjected to due to her feminine appearance.
“I believe that defining ourselves in our own terms and in our own languages is one of the most powerful and important rights that we have as human beings,” Manning said in a statement in response to the DOJ brief. “Presenting myself in the gender that I am is about my right to exist. What the government is basically telling me is ‘you cannot exist,’ that ‘you are wrong,’ and that ‘you do not exist.’ What they are doing is taking away our right to exist. I think this is the kind of situation that justifies all kinds of terrible things like ignorance, maltreatment, torture, murder, and genocide.
“Nobody knows your gender more than you do,” added Manning. “You do not know my gender better than I do. A doctor doesn’t know it better than me. My parents don’t know it better than me. No one experiences my gender in the way that I experience it. Gender presentation should reflect the person that you are. When you lose control of your gender presentation you lose an important aspect of your identity and existence.”
Chase Strangio, Manning’s lawyer from the ACLU’s Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Project, argues that the government is complicating the matter while also violating his client’s right to be “free from cruel and unusual punishment.”
“Chelsea’s demand is simple: that she be treated with her medically necessary treatment and like all other women in military custody,” Strangio said in a statement. “Her fight is central to the pursuit for justice for transgender people and for those who are incarcerated and we are honored to fight alongside her.”
A federal judge rejected a request from New York's Nassau County to block New York Attorney General Letitia James from taking legal action against the county for its law prohibiting transgender athletes from using county-owned sports venues.
In February, Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman, a Republican, issued an order denying permits for all county-run parks and sports facilities to any female-designated sports team that cannot provide evidence, including original birth certificates attesting that all their members were assigned female at birth.
Days later, James, a Democrat, sent Blakeman a letter telling him to rescind the order, on the grounds that it violates New York State's law prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation, gender identity, or gender expression. She called the order "transphobic and blatantly illegal."
On Tuesday, April 16, a federal appeals court voted to block a West Virginia law banning transgender student-athletes from competing on teams that align with their gender identity.
The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found that the ban, which was signed into law by Republican Gov. Jim Justice in April 2021, violates the rights of transgender students under Title IX, the federal statute that prohibits sex-based discrimination.
The law was challenged by a slew of civil rights and LGBTQ organizations on behalf of B.P.J., a 13-year-old transgender girl and middle school track and cross-country athlete who wishes to compete as a girl.
A Planet Fitness gym in Alaska banned an anti-LGBTQ woman who photographed a transgender member who was using the women's locker room.
Patricia Silva, a life coach from Fairbanks, Alaska, posted a public Facebook video on March 11, in which she claimed to have seen a "man shaving in the woman's bathroom" at the gym, reported the British tabloid Daily Mail.
"I realize he wants to be a woman, he gets to be a woman," Silva said in the video. "I love him in Christ. He's a spiritual being having a human experience. He doesn't like his gender, so he wants to be a woman, but I’m not comfortable with him shaving in my bathroom. All right. I just thought I'd say it out loud."
These are challenging times for news organizations. And yet it’s crucial we stay active and provide vital resources and information to both our local readers and the world. So won’t you please take a moment and consider supporting Metro Weekly with a membership? For as little as $5 a month, you can help ensure Metro Weekly magazine and MetroWeekly.com remain free, viable resources as we provide the best, most diverse, culturally-resonant LGBTQ coverage in both the D.C. region and around the world. Memberships come with exclusive perks and discounts, your own personal digital delivery of each week’s magazine (and an archive), access to our Member's Lounge when it launches this fall, and exclusive members-only items like Metro Weekly Membership Mugs and Tote Bags! Check out all our membership levels here and please join us today!