Metro Weekly

Theater Review: Rorschach Theatre’s Reykjavík

Husbands and hustlers explore sex, love, and violence in the saucy but unsatisfying Reykjavík.

Josh Adams and Robert Bowen Smith – Photo: C. Stanley Photography

It can be strangely refreshing to hear characters onstage speak the frank, profanity-laced language of contemporary bedroom conversation. And Steve Yockey’s Reykjavík (★★ out of five), an episodic escapade through the bars, backrooms and hotel rooms of the Icelandic capital, hits a sweet spot of real talk in its series of interludes including husbands on holiday (Dylan Arredondo and Robert Bowen Smith); a role-playing hustler (Josh Adams) and his john (Arredondo); and a tourist (Adams) who hooks up with a local or two (Arredondo and Carlos Saldaña).

The thrust of Yockey’s sardonic study of mostly gay male desire comes through clearly enough in Rick Hammerly’s staging for Rorschach Theatre inside the spacious Silver Spring Black Box. Nearly every character floating through Reykjavík in search of a transcendent love, or love affair, finds that mistrust or violence gets in the way.

But, as these bed-partners and bedroom scenes shuffle on and off, some of them amusing, others suspenseful, absurd, or just unconvincing, they don’t gather much cumulative effect. The messages remain mixed, or indistinct, as do several of the characterizations.

The multi-tasking, six-person ensemble, led by Adams and Arredondo, captures the script’s odd mood of sex, whimsy, and suspense. Tonally, it’s a not-surprising witches’ brew coming from a playwright who also writes and produces the CW’s long-running genre hit Supernatural. A few of the confessional, erotic episodes turn bloody, while the story of the married couple creeped out by ravens roosting outside their hotel window takes an intriguing turn towards the absurd.

Not just any old birds, these are observant, opinionated ravens — critics, if you will — who send terse notes to the hotel management offering analysis of everything they’ve observed in the husbands’ room.

Scenes between a hustler and john who either are playing out a rescue fantasy, or living through a horrifying reality, strike a less novel chord. Hammerly’s approach to the storyline, which might have brought some urgency and unexpected wit to a discussion of sex-trafficking, lands it squarely in the too-familiar realm of gay male fiction about damaged hustlers and johns.

Adams makes the hustler, Hank, an enigmatic manipulator, but doesn’t do enough to distinguish the guy from the other characters he’s playing. Perhaps his Hank and tourist James and lover Ebon are one person, or versions of one person. Maybe the ravens can tell us.

Carlos Saldana, Josh Adams and Dylan Arredondo – Photo: C. Stanley Photography

Arredondo, on the other hand, locates a different voice and center of gravity for each of his characters, including Robert and another who’s legitimately frightening. His performance might actually persuade some in the audience into believing they’re seeing two different actors from scene to scene. Dina Soltan also contributes an appealing versatility in a variety of supporting roles, and Jenna Rossman and Adams share a lovely latter scene between siblings.

Hammerly relies on Katie McCreary’s exceptional lighting design, as much as the actors, to distinguish plot, mood, and location. The lights, along with Kylos Brannon’s evocative video projections lend style, and, in the case of a momentary glimpse of the “Northern Lights,” some sweet spectacle to cut through the increasingly bitter taste of this cocktail of dour sexual encounters.

Reykjavík runs through March 3 at Silver Spring Black Box, 8641 Colesville Road in Silver Spring. Tickets are $20 to $30. Call 202-399-7993, or visit

Support Metro Weekly’s Journalism

These are challenging times for news organizations. And yet it’s crucial we stay active and provide vital resources and information to both our local readers and the world. So won’t you please take a moment and consider supporting Metro Weekly with a membership? For as little as $5 a month, you can help ensure Metro Weekly magazine and remain free, viable resources as we provide the best, most diverse, culturally-resonant LGBTQ coverage in both the D.C. region and around the world. Memberships come with exclusive perks and discounts, your own personal digital delivery of each week’s magazine (and an archive), access to our Member's Lounge when it launches this fall, and exclusive members-only items like Metro Weekly Membership Mugs and Tote Bags! Check out all our membership levels here and please join us today!