Metro Weekly

Texas judge removed from trans child custody case due to Facebook posting

Post called into question Judge Kim Cooks' impartiality in controversial custody case involving a transgender child

Dallas County Family Court Judge Kim Cooks – Photo: Facebook.

The judge in a highly-publicized and controversial Dallas child custody case has been removed from the case after posting about it on Facebook.

Dallas County Judge Tena Callahan granted the request of Anne Georgulas, the child’s mother, to forcibly recuse Judge Kim Cooks after it was revealed that Cooks had shared a Dallas Morning News story about the case on her official Facebook page in October — a move that could threaten her ability to remain impartial in the case. 

Another user had originally posted the story with the caption, “Here’s the truth! READ IT and THEN GO RUN TELL THAT!” In sharing that post, Cooks wrote: “[Neither] The Governor nor any legislature had any influence on the Court’s Decision.”

The post no longer appears on Cooks’ Facebook page, reports The Dallas Morning News.

“Given the presiding judge’s comments about the case on her social media accounts, we believe recusal was the appropriate response and are pleased with Judge Callahan’s order, which will mean a new judge now will make any remaining decisions in the case,” Georgulas’ attorney Chad Baruch said in an email to The Dallas Morning News.

Georgulas’ attorneys filed a motion last month urging the court to allow Georgulas to have sole custody of her child and the child’s twin. Georgulas has claimed the child is transgender, and had sought to modify an existing joint custody agreement with her ex-husband if he did not allow the child to transition by dressing and being referred to as a girl.

But the child’s father, Jeffrey Younger, has disputed the notion that his child is transgender, arguing that the child accepts dressing and being referred to as a boy when they spend time together.

Younger has previously claimed that his ex-wife will try to “chemically castrate” the child if the 7-year-old is allowed to transition. But Georgulas disputes that notion, saying she only wants to allow her child to socially transition, and would not place the child on medication or hormones at such a young age.

Younger had filed for sole custody of the children, but a jury in the custody case said that the children should be placed under sole custody — but not under him. Instead, Cooks upheld the existing joint custody agreement, placing a gag order on both parents not to talk about the case and ordering the family to undergo therapy.

In her decision, Cooks noted that Georgulas had not sought sole custody of the children, and said that both parents needed to make decisions about the child’s transition. But Georgulas’ attorneys have argued that the jury’s decision not to place the children with younger is the same as granting sole custody to Georgulas.

An administrative judge will appoint a new judge to oversee the case. That judge will then rule on the motion from Georgulas’ lawyers regarding what the jury’s decision about custody entails.

The case has received much press, particularly from conservative media outlets, who have pointed to the case as an example of a politically-correct, left-wing ideology being advanced that will harm children by indoctrinating them into identifying as transgender. As a result, lawmakers in Texas, as well as other states like Georgia and Kentucky, have begun proposing bills to prohibit any minor from undergoing a gender transition, and punishing doctors or parents who assist a child in transitioning.

Read more:


Blind transgender woman in Washington State assaulted in possible hate crime

Transgender mural in Dallas defaced with mustaches

Gilead Sciences gives $4.5 million to support transgender-led health initiatives

Please Support LGBTQ Journalism

As a free LGBTQ publication, Metro Weekly relies on advertising in order to bring you unique, high quality journalism, both online and in our weekly edition. The ongoing coronavirus pandemic has forced many of our incredible advertisers to temporarily close their doors to protect staff and customers, and so we’re asking you, our readers, to help support Metro Weekly during this trying period. We appreciate anything you can do, and please keep reading us on the website and our new Digital Edition, released every Thursday and available for online reading or download.

John Riley is the local news reporter for Metro Weekly. He can be reached at

Leave a Comment:

Like What You're Reading?

Get Metro Weekly's Daily Email