Metro Weekly

‘Show Pony’ EP review: Orville Peck releases a clever, haunting collection of songs

The enigmatic Orville Peck's plaintive classic country EP is a perfect send-off to a lonely pandemic-stricken summer

show pony, orville peck, music, album, country
Orville Peck — Photo: Carlos Santololla

Anyone who listened to Orville Peck’s debut album Pony can tell you that his carefully crafted melancholy loner persona goes far deeper than his signature fringe masks. True, country aesthetics are having a bit of an extended moment right now, but if Peck hasn’t already proven himself to be more than a one-off gimmick, his follow-up EP, Show Pony (★★★★☆) drives the point home. On its opener, “Summertime,” Peck delivers an emotional gut punch with his Johnny Cash-adjacent vocals coming close to breaking over the refrain, “I miss summertime.” In any other year, it would have been eyebrow-raisingly odd to release a song nostalgic for summer at the beginning of the season and now leading an album released in the waning weeks of summer, but in fact, Peck couldn’t have picked a better time for it.

Peck keeps up a streak of heavy-handed downers with “No Glory in the West” and “Kids,” but just when the lonely cowboy vibes start to weigh a little too heavy, he picks up the mood with “Legends Never Die,” a duet with pop-country legend Shania Twain. A collaboration between a queer country artist and a gay icon of sorts could have easily leaned into full camp, but instead ends up as a timeless radio-friendly number. It’s a little more upbeat than what Peck usually goes for and a little more subdued than Shania’s biggest hits, the two coming together in the middle for a moment of pure pop-country levity. On top of everything, the pair clearly have had a lot of fun working together, and their joy on the track and the recently released video is infectious.

Peck is definitely at home playing with the styles and themes of classic country, but is also not shy about bringing a level of overt queerness into his work. Recalling the over-the-top glamorous western drag pageantry of “Queen of the Rodeo,” the music video for “Legends Never Die” features a handful of notable cameos, including a voiceover by John Waters and an appearance from Drag Race winner Jaida Essence Hall.

Orville Peck: Show Pony EP

Beyond the in-your-face queerness of the video is the more subversive queerness of his cover of Bobbie Gentry’s “Fancy.” Covering “Fancy” at all is a bold choice for the deep-voiced crooner like Peck, and he leans into it hard, putting an unexpectedly dark spin on it with a palpable anger in his voice and thudding instrumentals that bring out new levels of intensity and pathos in an already iconic song. Peck also gives us a touching homoromantic moment on “Drive Me, Crazy,” a song that tells a lonely yet touching story of one trucker pining for another.

Orville Peck gracefully walks this line between the romantic solitary masculinity of the imaginary old west and a specific sort of queerness that may appear to sit uncomfortably alongside it, but has always been there for those who have cared to look for it. As brief as Show Pony is, it is a clever, haunting collection of songs that shows a somewhat more versatile side of the mysterious gay cowboy that Pony introduced us to.

Show Pony is now available to stream and purchase.

Orville Peck’s Second Annual Rodeo will livestream from the Vogue Theatre on Sunday August 29 at 9 p.m. ET. Featuring remote performances by Evil, Dale Hollow & the Long Con, Louisiana Purchase and Miss Toto. Tickets are $15. Visit

Support Metro Weekly’s Journalism

These are challenging times for news organizations. And yet it’s crucial we stay active and provide vital resources and information to both our local readers and the world. So won’t you please take a moment and consider supporting Metro Weekly with a membership? For as little as $5 a month, you can help ensure Metro Weekly magazine and remain free, viable resources as we provide the best, most diverse, culturally-resonant LGBTQ coverage in both the D.C. region and around the world. Memberships come with exclusive perks and discounts, your own personal digital delivery of each week’s magazine (and an archive), access to our Member's Lounge when it launches this fall, and exclusive members-only items like Metro Weekly Membership Mugs and Tote Bags! Check out all our membership levels here and please join us today!